The Daily Gazette - Schenectady, NY
Daily Gazette

Tortured debate
Saturday, September 27, 2008

I don’t know who won the great presidential debate, but I’ll tell you what most struck me, what, in fact, almost knocked me out of my chair. Two things actually.

First, John McCain saying early in the debate that he “opposed President Bush on torture.”

Second, Barack Obama saying later in the debate, “I give Sen. McCain great credit on the torture issue.”

It was fit for Alice in Wonderland.

True, McCain opposed Bush on torture back in 2005, but in February of this year, when the Senate passed a bill to specifically bar the CIA from using such techniques as waterboarding, forced nudity, electric shocks and attack dogs and limit it to the military’s approved techniques, McCain voted against that bill, saying the CIA needed its own “extra measures,” and he urged President Bush to veto the bill, which Bush did.

Can you imagine the effrontery for him now to boast that he opposed Bush on torture?

And can you imagine the opacity, or the cunning – I don’t know which – for Obama to give him credit for it?

I will have more to say on this subject in my column in the print version of the Daily Gazette.




comments

September 27, 2008
8:01 p.m.

[ Suggest removal ]
ehgauss ( no real name given ) says...

I have to assume that Senator McCain, having been tortured as a POW, can speak on the subject of POW torture with more authority than either you or I. Neither of us are in a position to second guess him on this issue. I'm willing to defer to Sen. McCain on how to use it in the defense of our country and I would guess that Obama is smart enough to know he has no basis for an opinion either.

October 1, 2008
11:08 a.m.

[ Suggest removal ]
williepitt ( no real name given ) says...

Well, ehgauss, I'm not willing to assume that because McCain was tortured, he's the final word on whether the US government should use torture. Especially when his final word is cuckoo.

Post a comment
(Requires free registration.)

In Today's Gazette...
December 3, 2008

Poll
How do you expect your holiday shopping habits to change this year?







See the results


Services



Ask A Doctor