Lessons of the shutdown

Friday, October 18, 2013
Text Size: A | A

Well, that worked, didn’t it? Shutting down parts of the government for two and a half weeks and coming this close to default and economic disaster showed that the Republicans were serious about ... what was it, exactly? Something about not liking big government, or debt, or an already-passed bill that tries to make sure all Americans have health insurance, or President Obama, we think. In the end, their message was like a tale told by an idiot, full of sound and fury, signifying nothing.

Would they dare do it again in a few months, after Wednesday’s deal that temporarily raises the debt limit, allows spending and even pays furloughed workers expires?

Not if they listened to the financial markets and American people, who were appalled at what was going on and placed most of the blame on the Republicans.

Not if they listened to their leaders, but that has been the problem all along. That, and the leaders themselves, who have been unwilling or unable to control those who would put gestures before governing.

So, another game of chicken (Russian Roulette may be more apt) is less likely now, but by no means impossible.

This is a victory for the president and Democrats. There can be no mistake about that. But the only way to turn it into a lasting one, for themselves and the country, is to take the Republicans’ concerns about the debt seriously, make a real effort to engage them between now and January, and make some progress on a deficit-reduction plan.

The bipartisan congressional budget committee appointed as part of Wednesday's deal is the place to start. Everything needs to be on the table — not just increasing taxes and cutting defense spending, but tax code and entitlement reforms (if tax increases were presented as part of these, the Republicans might find them more palatable).

This was a crisis, one that the Republicans created and that threatened to destroy their party. The American people, having been put through it, now deserve what they haven’t had for some time (partly through their own fault): people in Washington who can work together for the good of the country.

Share story: print print email email facebook facebook reddit reddit


October 18, 2013
7:47 a.m.
fjcjr says...

The Republicans deserve most of the blame for this budget showdown, but the Democrats and Obama do too. The comments Harry Reid makes, and no one calls him on are incendiary, and juvenile. Our dear president displays no leadership whatsoever - he doesn't call, and doesn't write, but rather goes to play golf. His leadership skills would be inadequate for the student council. Moreover, it seems he really likes the trappings of the job - plane, house, and helicopter, but appears to have no interest in the job itself. So the right can take their deserved blame, but to ingore the culpability of the left in Washington's disfuntion is refusing to acknowledge the obvious.

October 18, 2013
9:14 a.m.
roberttodt says...

Let's see, as Senator Obama, he spoke against our increasing debt, said the average person was paying to much of the taxes and spoke out against raising the debt ceiling over and over. The people listened and gave him his chance. Now President Obama stomps his feet and won't talk about his solutions. Increasing the debt and raising taxes more than any other president. Passing a health care law that puts the main burden on the youth and middle class of the country, while skyrocketing their costs. That's a great solution.
In the end, all will discover who was fighting for them, and was fighting for themselves.

October 19, 2013
7:35 a.m.
wmarincic says...

The Republicans were doing their job, it was Obama and the Senate that said they would not negotiate. That is the way government is supposed to work, Congress passes a bill, it goes to the Senate who makes their changes and then it goes to conference to iron out the differences and then the President either signs it or sends it back to be worked on some more until all agree. Obama was the responsible one here with his little hatchet man, Harry Reid.

Log-in to post a comment.

columnists & blogs

Log into

Forgot Password?