Robert Scheer: War on Obamacare racism-based

Monday, October 14, 2013
Text Size: A | A

Before he was disgraced into resigning his presidency over the Watergate burglary scandal, Richard Nixon had successfully engineered an even more odious plot known as his Southern Strategy. The trick was devilishly simple: Appeal to the persistent racist inclination of Southern whites by abandoning the Republican Party’s historic association with civil rights and demonizing the black victims of the South’s history of segregation.

That same divisive strategy is at work in the Republican rejection of the Affordable Care Act. GOP governors are largely in control of the 26 states, including all but Arkansas in the South, that have refused to implement the act’s provision for an expansion of Medicaid to cover the millions of American working poor who earn too much to qualify for the program now. A New York Times analysis of census data concludes that as a result of the Republican governors’ resistance, “A sweeping national effort to extend health coverage to millions of Americans will leave out two-thirds of the poor blacks and single mothers and more than half of the lowwage workers who do not have insurance, the very kinds of people that the program was intended to help.”

Why anyone who claims to be pro-life would want to deny health care to single mothers is an enduring mystery in the morally mischievous ethos of the Republican Party. But the exclusion of a working poor population that skews disproportionately black in the South is simply a continuation of the divide-and-conquer politics that have formed Republican strategy since Nixon.

The game plan of gutting the Affordable Care Act despite its passage into law and before its positive outcomes are demonstrated can be traced to a “blueprint to defunding Obamacare” initialed by the GOP conservative leadership under the aegis of Heritage Action for America. Ironically, that is the political front of the Heritage Foundation, the leading GOP think tank that is credited by some architects of Obamacare as the initial inspiration of their health care program. The difference is that whereas the Heritage Foundation was pushing a mild health care reform based on increased profit for private insurers, as in the plan Mitt Romney introduced in Massachusetts, the Republicans object to the provisions in this president’s program that broaden access for the needy.

They were abetted in this decision by a Supreme Court ruling last year granting the states the option of not expanding Medicaid to cover the uninsured under the new act. As a consequence, 8 million of our fellow Americans with annual incomes of less than $19,530 for a family of three have been prevented from obtaining the health care coverage that we as a nation decided to grant them.

It might seem odd for governors to reject a program to help those living in their state that is fully funded by the federal government for the first few years and then 90 percent covered by the feds thereafter. But turning down a federal program to aid your own state’s population makes perfect sense when connected with the racist appeal initiated by Nixon that has turned the once-Democratic South into a rock-solid Republican bastion. There are certainly many whites among the 435,000 cashiers, 341,000 cooks and 253,000 nurses aides who the Times estimated will be denied needed health care in the states controlled by Republican governors who have decided to veto the most important provision of the Affordable Care Act.

In the end, this is a replay of the civil rights drama that gripped the nation more than half a century ago, but back then the Republican Party, following the enlightened leadership of Dwight Eisenhower, was on the humanitarian side of the equation. Now the elected leaders of a party that has been on the side of emancipation since the presidency of Abraham Lincoln acts to deny the basic human right to life-sustaining health care to the Southern progeny of slaves. As the Times study noted: “In all, 6 out of 10 blacks live in the states not expanding Medicaid. In Mississippi, 56 percent of all poor and uninsured adults are black, though they account for just 38 percent of the population.”

But that also means that almost 44 percent of the poor and uninsured in Mississippi are white, and the gutting of this program that hurts them is evidence of the false consciousness that informs racist appeals. As the Times points out, someone, black or white, making $11,000 a year frying chicken in a convenience store falls into the gap of making too much to qualify for the state’s existing Medicaid program but not enough to be subsidized under the new health care plan as the state defines it. For those who lose out, there’s what the Republican die-hards call tough love. That’s not love. It’s hate.

Robert Scheer is a nationally syndicated columnist.

Share story: print print email email facebook facebook reddit reddit


October 14, 2013
6:50 a.m.
Phils2008 says...

What a pile of pure crap. Your idiot party hurts blacks on a daily bases. People could afford health care if they had jobs, but you Democrats have been destroying them at record pace. The ACA was a lie is a lie and will be a financial disaster for this country. Like most of the lefts loser ideas, when this one fails you'll be barking that all it needs is more money more money. Blacks are on the Democrats plantation not the Republicans, so you can shove your racism crap.

October 14, 2013
9:22 a.m.
ChuckD says...

And whatever you said after 'Your idiot party hurts blacks..." doesn't amount to a hill 'o beans to most adults.

October 14, 2013
3:38 p.m.
gina99 says...

Obamacare is opposed by anyone that can do basic math. Black, white or green. The funding is not in place and the numbers never add up. Some of us are not thrilled by tripling our health insurance rates.

October 15, 2013
6:17 a.m.
Phils2008 says...

ChuckD, The reason it wont matter to anyone in your party is adults are far and few between. The use of racism by you liberals is simply to garner votes. Nothing more nothing less. Oppose any liberal crackpot idea and your a racist. Its your constant cry of racism that doesn't amount to a hill of beans!

October 15, 2013
6:10 p.m.
ChuckD says...

89% of the Republican Party are non-Hispanic whites.
Your 800 pound gorilla.

October 15, 2013
6:45 p.m.
Phils2008 says...

ChuckD, common sense is something that appears to avoid you like the plague. Your party excoriates any black that dares to leave the plantation and join the Republican party and you cite that as proof of racism. You steal money from working men and women and hold it out like candy to buy memberships. You destroy jobs to ensure your members are dependent on your handouts. You offer nothing to minorities other then handouts, Their fear of losing the goodies is the only reason your messiah won a second term. Rip the 89% as hard as you want, they're the ones paying for all you lefty free loaders.

October 16, 2013
8:40 p.m.
pnotto says...

Any time when a liberal like ChuckD opens his mouth fecal matter dribbles out. No where in his postings does any form of sense emerge to try and defend his lame position(s), instead there is stupid idiotic ideological lack of logic that comes forth. In his useless rants of idiocy comes to the forefront his parties philosophy of the way America should be. The only thing he has to offer are the usual rhetoric of calling people names to try employ some white guilt in an effort to silence debate and/or opinion. The old saying goes, "out of the mouths of fools and babes comes pearls of honesty and wisdom," but in ChuckD's case neither is evident in his case. More like foolishness. Like the other idiots who write postings I am still waiting with baited breath for him and his nit wit buds on the left to actually offer something that is worth debating. Instead these people live in Disney Land with their liberal ideology...

Log-in to post a comment.

columnists & blogs

Log into

Forgot Password?