Report: New York per-pupil spending tops in nation

Saturday, June 8, 2013
Text Size: A | A

— New York has the highest per-pupil spending in the nation, according to a new analysis by the Citizens Budget Commission.

From fiscal year 2010 to 2011, average spending per pupil in the Empire State increased from $18,618 to $19,076, more than 80 percent above the U.S. average, according to the CBC, a nonprofit organization that monitors and researches government finances and advocates for budget reform.

“A lot of times there’s this misconception that New York has an underfunded educational system,” said Elizabeth Lynam, vice president and director of state studies for the CBC. “But there’s more money spent on education in New York per pupil than anywhere else.”

By the numbers

Per-pupil spending figures for a handful of local districts:

• Schenectady City School District — $16,015

• Shenendehowa Central School District — $13,944

• Mohonasen Central School District — $13,361

• Gloversville Enlarged School District — $14,229

• Middleburgh Central School District — $19,968

• Greater Amsterdam School District — $14,892

Source: Citizens Budget Commission

She said there are “distribution issues” — some districts are extremely well-funded while others are not — but the state’s overall education spending is more than adequate.

“Even in this era of budget cuts, we’ve managed to increase education spending,” she said, adding that how school aid is distributed is “a very rich topic.”

Carl Korn, chief press officer for the New York State United Teachers union, blasted the CBC report. He said it should come as no surprise that New York has such high per-pupil spending costs, considering how expensive it is to live in the state, particularly in New York City, Long Island and other downstate suburbs.

“Putting out a report saying that New York leads the country in education spending is like saying the sky is blue,” Korn said.

He noted that the median home sale price in Westchester County is more than $500,000.

“What are teachers in Westchester County supposed to do — live in the North Country and take Amtrak down every day?” he said. “This report fails to provide the necessary context and facts.

“You don’t have to be a rocket scientist to understand that everything costs more in New York.”

Spending varies by region, with districts in Long Island and other suburbs of New York City outspending their upstate peers. Another area of high spending is the Adirondacks, which Lynam attributed to “extremely tiny enrollment” and “huge ancillary costs of transportation” in the region’s more remote districts.

In the Capital Region, per-pupil spending is lower than the state average, according to the CBC.

Korn said New York’s schools generally perform well in rankings and assessments, which suggests the state’s money is well spent. He pointed out that Education Week, a national newspaper that covers K-12 education, recently ranked New York third of all 50 states in its annual state report cards; these report cards grade states in six areas of educational policy and performance.

“There are a lot of successes in the New York public education system,” Korn said.

According to the CBC, New York’s high spending is driven by two factors: salaries and benefits such as health insurance. Instructional salaries in New York average $8,196 per pupil, nearly double the U.S. average of $4,326, while fringe benefits cost New York districts an average of $3,962 per pupil, versus an average of $1,505 nationwide.

“We certainly have well-compensated teachers,” Lynam said. “And we certainly don’t want to be at the bottom of the pack. But we’re so far from that that we could be having a conversation about salaries and benefits.”

The report notes that between fiscal year 2010 to 2011 average spending per pupil for the 50 states and Washington, D.C., fell 0.4 percent, from $10,600 to $10,540. New York was one of 30 states where per-pupil spending increased, and had the highest per-pupil spending in the country in each of the previous five years.

Other high-spending states include New Jersey, which spent $15,968 per pupil in 2010-11, and Connecticut, which spent $15,600.

The data in the CBC report comes from the U.S. Census Bureau, and is the most recent available, according to the CBC.

“This is the first time since the Census began collecting this data [in 1974] that year-to-year spending in the U.S. has gone down,” Lynam said. “But in New York it’s gone up.”

Share story: print print email email facebook facebook reddit reddit


June 9, 2013
7:36 a.m.
gina99 says...

Highest spending for the worst results. NYS schools need to stop unnecessary noneducational programs and go to the Florida one superintendent per county system. In Schenectady County alone that would save $20 million a year.

June 9, 2013
6:24 p.m.
wmarincic says...

If we spend another 100 million we will graduate at a 59% rate rather than a 58% rate.

June 9, 2013
7:17 p.m.
birmy says...

Elizabeth Lynam, vice president and director of state studies for the CBC, stated “Even in this era of budget cuts, we’ve managed to increase education spending,” she said, adding that how school aid is distributed is “a very rich topic.”

Her statement is misleading. State aid levels are lower than they were 4 years ago. So if you punch someone in the stomach and take $50 and then give them back $30 over a period of 4 years it seems disingenuous to state we've increased education spending. While a technically accurate statement that she said it is very misleading. Don't you think?

In 1991 a family health insurance plan was $2,000. It is now $15,000-$18,000. Do we blame the teachers for maintaining quality insurance or do we blame the health insurance industry? NYS pensions are expensive and that is why new teachers under Tier 6 will work until they are 63 and pay 49% of all the costs associated with their defined benefit. Do state, city, county workers, police and fire get the same pension? For the most part YES!

Teachers in NYS have a high per pupil spending amount but the article did not detail why? Do we have more teachers in NYS than other states? Do we have more administrators? Do we have more transportation costs? Is the pension the #1 determinant in why NYS costs more? Why are we $2,600 more per pupil than NJ? Do we have more school building projects? 50 million here and 50 million there?

I know teachers cannot abuse overtime as I have written before. Teachers cannot earn more than 10% of their base salary doing the chess club or coaching. So we know overtime is not the reason. Is the reason that we have close to 900 school districts? You would not know by reading this article.

I hear a lot of people stating how bad NYS schools are. My neighbor used to live in Alburquerque, NM. He said his taxes increased 3 fold when he came to NYS but he did not mind. He said the school system where he lived was outright awful. I think people look at the graduation rates of inner city schools and they go "gotcha, NYS schools are terrible." The graduation rate in suburban schools is great. No one has a definitive answer for inner city schools. That is why NYS schools get so much bad press. What is the answer?

Log-in to post a comment.

columnists & blogs

Log into

Forgot Password?