Volunteer firefighters may be a case of ‘you get what you pay for’

Saturday, January 12, 2013
Text Size: A | A

Volunteer firefighters may be a case of ‘you get what you pay for’

Re Justin Mason’s Jan. 6 article, “Residents face cost to maintain 8 fire companies”: Mr. Mason did a good job reporting on how expensive new firehouses can be, [but] a few facts need to be clarified.

The number of calls in Rotterdam is exaggerated: There are some where more than one fire department responds. So when two or three fire departments respond to one call, it’s counted as a call for each fire department — not one call for the town. Since there’s no shared information between fire departments, there are duplications of fire reports for the same incident. So the reported number of 1,522 could easily be cut in half — more or less.

Next, comparing Rotterdam to the Schenectady Fire Department: Yes, salaries are a factor in the higher cost, but the Schenectady Fire Department does offer far more [service] than Rotterdam. For example, Schenectady firefighters routinely do hazardous materials response for the county, water rescue, and advance life support.

A little-known fact about volunteers is that money is put aside in an interest-bearing retirement fund for certain firefighters approved by the district. So technically, they’re not [working] for free, but are getting a stipend which isn’t collected until they’re in their 60s.

Another thing: There is no training standard for volunteer firefighters per state law. Professional (paid) firefighters [must] achieve 229 hours for their initial training, plus an additional 100 hours of training each year. Volunteers just need to maintain eight hours of OSHA training each year. It’s up to each fire department to make sure that their volunteers are trained to maintain some service to their community.

Unfortunately, the average person doesn’t know just how well trained the volunteers are and whether the officers are elected on merit or popularity. These factors can compromise the performance of the district.

The consolidation of some districts/services would be helpful, but volunteerism is not always the answer for less expensive and better service.

Timothy J. Gaffney Jr.


The writer is a former Rotterdam volunteer firefighter and is currently employed by the Latham Fire Department.

Reilly’s ‘Lincoln’ piece spurs other memories

Being a Civil War history buff, I read Ed Reilly’s Jan. 6 Viewpoint [“‘Lincoln’ prompts recollections of Capital Region connections”] about President Lincoln with great interest.

Ironically, it is little known that the elder brother of John Wilkes Booth, who assassinated President Lincoln, actually saved the president’s son, Robert Todd Lincoln.

“Todd” Lincoln was on his way back to Washington, and on a train platform in Jersey City, N.J., (circa 1864-65) and was accidentally pushed by the crowd between a railway car and the platform as the train started to move. He was pulled back by Edwin Booth and saved from serious harm or death. The young Lincoln recognized him immediately and thanked him for his deed.

Having researched and presented on the founder of the Union Army Signal Corps, I’m presently researching the U.S. Military Telegraph. As many know, President Lincoln spent much time in the telegraph room at the War Department, adjacent to the office of “Old Mars” (Edwin McHale Stanton), secretary of war.

Stanton kept a strict oversight of the telegraph system. The president would walk to the War Department and be informed via telegraph messages about theater operations. He would also nap there in the afternoon occasionally.

I would like to thank [Reilly] for his kind words about the Wemple family and the individuals mentioned. He has always had a way with words. As a 10th generation descendant of Jan Barentse Wemple (Wemp) arriving at Fort Orange, circa 1643, and one of the founding fathers of Schenectady, I have always been interested in the city.

Ray Wemple


To stop the violence, we must remove the guns

Re David Petronis’ Jan. 8 letter, “Despite protests, Saratoga gun show will go on as scheduled”: I’m appealing to all Americans to take back America. We also have our rights to live in a society without guns.

The increase in violence — the accidental handling of firearms, domestic violence, mass shootings — is a problem every day throughout the whole country and is getting worse. The government has done nothing over the many years and now it’s an epidemic.

How to stop this insane violence? The young wouldn’t have had handguns if there were none made. Accidentally firing at someone, killing a person, would not have happened if they didn’t have a gun.

In a domestic argument, the hate at that moment becomes a time to destroy each other — by a gun.

Handguns and semiautomatics, especially, need to [be] removed from our society now. Gun owners need to stop being selfish [about] their little hobby and stop stuffing it down our throats with their stupid, demanding ways.

Let’s clean [up] our America; write to our government and make them listen to us. I will.

Ruth Benacquista


Letters Policy

The Gazette wants your opinions on public issues.

There is no strict word limit, though letters under 200 words are preferred.

All letters are subject to editing for length, style and fairness, and we will run no more than one letter per month from the same writer.

Please include your signature, address and day phone for verification.

For information on how to send, see bottom of this page.

For more letters, visit our Web site:

Share story: print print email email facebook facebook reddit reddit


January 12, 2013
7:48 a.m.
wmarincic says...

Ruth Benacquista I know you liberals hate facts but here they are. The UK where there is an absolute gun ban.. Last year they were number 1 in violent crime in the world. They had 1,158,957 VIOLENT CRIME incidences last year, that is 2034 acts per 100,000 residence. The next 9 countries in the world with the highest acts of violent crime are,Austria, South Africa,Sweden, Belgium, Canada, Finland,Netherlands, Luxenburg and France. The United States is so far down the list of violent crime it's not worth mentioning. What makes us safe is guns..... You want to stop 60 percent of the violence? Close the borders, the South American gang members are creating much of it. Bring our soldiers home and let them patrol the borders and team up with local police in gang hotspots.

January 12, 2013
8:41 a.m.
gina99 says...

Ruth Benacquista-more simplistic platitudes. We are not going to rip up our Bill of Rights to appease the anti-gun corner. Would you be happier when knife deaths skyrocket? Too many on on the streets who need mental health care.

January 12, 2013
2:50 p.m.
janesjoys says...

I know why gun sales are soaring. We have former Illionois Congressman (R) Joe Walsh ranting that we may need to shed blood to to "keep this great Republic". Then the CEO of Tactical Response, James Yager, in our faces stating he is ready to fire the first shot and start killing people. Is he the good guy or the bad guy of whom the NRA speaks? Anyway, I'm heading to the gun show, along with probably hundreds of others, to get some fire power to protect myself from these scary violent 2nd Amendment proponents. I'll bet a good percentage of the sales are people like me. I don't want to take your guns, but I do want to feel safe to exercise my 1st Amendment rights and live without fear of being shot at the mall. I don't feel so safe right now.

January 12, 2013
4:29 p.m.
wmarincic says...


January 12, 2013
5:46 p.m.
albright1 says...

good for you Janesjoy. Buy a firearm. Be sure to sign up for a NRA Firearm safety course prior to buying any ammunition. You will have a solemn responsibility to be a safe firearms owner.

January 12, 2013
6:03 p.m.
Fritzdawg says...

James Yager, CEO of Tactical Response, had his concealed carry permit taken away yesterday, by the state of Tennessee.
Which is as it should be.
I'm not anti gun, but when somebody is quite publicly ranting that he's about to shoot people, it would be irresponsible of them to let him keep it.

January 13, 2013
2:42 a.m.
janesjoys says...

albright1 - already took the course back in the 1960s. I grew up with guns for sport and hunting. I shot skeet for years with my husband, a state champion and chief referree in the state where we lived at the time. Funny, I can't remember ever needing an assualt weapon or 30 clip magazine to hit those little clay birds.

Fritzdawg - Did they take away his assault weapons and ammo? I am not sure how easily you can conceal some of those. But, anyway, good for Tennessee.

January 13, 2013
11:09 a.m.
albright1 says...

well Janesjoy, if you already own weapons, why did you make a comment leading us to believe that were going to break ground and go get some "firepower"? I question your honesty.

January 14, 2013
10:24 p.m.
wmarincic says...

I already said it albright1 hypocrite

Log-in to post a comment.

columnists & blogs

Log into

Forgot Password?